Penny Candy by the Pound Store/Penny Candy, Chocolates & Gift Boxes/Penny Candy by the PoundThe Brewster Store’s old fashioned candy counter offers a very wide assortment of penny candies.Refine by Sort byWe recommendNewest arrivalsPrice: Low to HighPrice: High to LowName: A to ZName: Z to AFiltersClear allFiltersClear allPrice Clear PriceClearfrom – to$5$21ApplyApplySort by Sort byWe recommendNewest arrivalsPrice: Low to HighPrice: High to LowName: A to ZName: Z to AApplyApplyShow itemsShow itemsBlack Licorice BitesBlack Licorice Bites$6.95 Buy NowBlack Licorice ButtonsBlack Licorice Buttons$8.95 Buy NowDark Chocolate Almond BarkDark Chocolate Almond Bark$18.95 Buy NowDark Chocolate GingerDark Chocolate Ginger$15.95 Buy NowChocolate Sea Salt CaramelsChocolate Sea Salt Caramels$18.95 Buy NowGreen Apple Jelly BeansGreen Apple Jelly Beans$5.95 Buy NowLemon Jelly BeansLemon Jelly Beans$5.95 Buy NowOld Fashioned Jelly BeansOld Fashioned Jelly Beans$5.95 Buy NowRock Candy on a StringRock Candy on a String$12.95 Buy NowVery Cherry Jelly BeansVery Cherry Jelly Beans$5.95 Buy NowBoston Baked BeansBoston Baked Beans$7.95 Buy NowHolland mintsHolland mints$17.95 Buy NowCandy LegosCandy Legos$8.95 Buy NowDark Chocolate Malted BallsDark Chocolate Malted Balls$18.95 Buy NowChocolate Malted Milk BallsChocolate Malted Milk Balls$13.95 Buy NowNon-Pareils (Snow Caps)Non-Pareils (Snow Caps)$20.95 Buy NowRiver RocksRiver Rocks$15.95 Buy NowSea ShellsSea Shells$15.95 Buy NowSmooth & Melty MintsSmooth & Melty Mints$9.95 Buy NowCinnamon ImperialsCinnamon Imperials$8.95 Buy NowOrange SlicesOrange Slices$6.95 Buy NowSpearmint LeavesSpearmint Leaves$5.95 Buy NowBeach PebblesBeach Pebbles$15.95 Buy Now
