Penny Candy Store/Food and Candy/Penny CandyThe Brewster Store’s old fashioned candy counter offers a very wide assortment of penny candies.Refine by Sort byWe recommendNewest arrivalsPrice: Low to HighPrice: High to LowName: A to ZName: Z to AFiltersClear allFiltersClear allPrice Clear PriceClearfrom – to$4$18ApplyApplySort by Sort byWe recommendNewest arrivalsPrice: Low to HighPrice: High to LowName: A to ZName: Z to AApplyApplyShow itemsShow itemsCandy LegosCandy Legos$8.95Candy-Chocolate covered Sea ShellsCandy-Chocolate covered Sea Shells$10.95Candy-River StonesCandy-River Stones$10.95Candy-Boston Baked BeansCandy-Boston Baked Beans$7.95Sold outCandy-Rock CandyCandy-Rock Candy$8.95Sold outChocolate covered espresso beansChocolate covered espresso beans$15.95Candy-chocolate covered Beach PebblesCandy-chocolate covered Beach Pebbles$10.95Candy-Spearmint LeavesCandy-Spearmint Leaves$5.95Candy-Cinnamon ImperialsCandy-Cinnamon Imperials$8.95Candy-Licorice PastelsCandy-Licorice Pastels$8.95Old Fashioned Jelly BeansOld Fashioned Jelly Beans$5.95Old Fashioned Spice GumDropsOld Fashioned Spice GumDrops$4.95Malted Milk BallsMalted Milk Balls$10.95Non-Pareils (Snow Caps)Non-Pareils (Snow Caps)$17.95Candy-Dutch mintsCandy-Dutch mints$12.95Candy-Orange SlicesCandy-Orange Slices$5.95Sold outCandy-licorice BitesCandy-licorice Bites$8.95
