Penny Candy, Chocolates & Gift Boxes

The Brewster Store’s old fashioned candy counter offers a wide assortment of treats for even the most serious candy connoisseurs.

Our fudge and salt water taffy make a delicious treat and the perfect gift for someone you’re sweet on. And our Penny Candies will take you back in time. Just as good as they were "in the day", these candies are sold by the pound and can be shipped right to your door.