Nostalgic Candy Store/Penny Candy, Chocolates & Gift Boxes/Nostalgic CandyRefine by Sort byWe recommendNewest arrivalsPrice: Low to HighPrice: High to LowName: A to ZName: Z to AFiltersClear allFiltersClear allPrice Clear PriceClearfrom – to$0$8ApplyApplySort by Sort byWe recommendNewest arrivalsPrice: Low to HighPrice: High to LowName: A to ZName: Z to AApplyApplyShow itemsShow itemsButterscotch SwizzlersButterscotch Swizzlers$0.50 Buy NowCherry SwizzlersCherry Swizzlers$0.50 Buy NowCinnamon SwizzlersCinnamon Swizzlers$0.50 Buy NowSold outCotton Candy SwizzlersCotton Candy Swizzlers$0.50Out of stockLemon SwizzlersLemon Swizzlers$0.50 Buy NowPeppermint SwizzlersPeppermint Swizzlers$0.50 Buy NowRoot Beer SwizzlersRoot Beer Swizzlers$0.50 Buy NowCranberry Bog Frogs, 1.9 ozCranberry Bog Frogs, 1.9 oz$5.00 Buy NowDark Chocolate Cranberries, 4 ozDark Chocolate Cranberries, 4 oz$8.00 Buy NowMilk Chocolate Cranberries, 4 ozMilk Chocolate Cranberries, 4 oz$8.00 Buy NowSalt Water TaffySalt Water Taffy$8.00 Buy Now
