The Brewster Store’s old fashioned candy counter offers a very wide assortment of penny candies, taffy, fudge, jelly beans and gum drops. The Brewster Store’s fudge and salt water taffy make a delicious treat and the perfect gift for someone you’re “sweet on.”

If you prefer an old-fashioned treat, take yourself back in time with our assorted Penny Candies. Just as good as they were years ago, these candies can be shipped right to your home.